Skip to main content

​
Multi-Tier Dispute Resolution System

​
1. Overview

When you reject expert work that doesn’t meet your specifications, the Multi-Tier Dispute Resolution System protects your escrow funds while ensuring fair, fast resolution. The system uses AI to resolve most disputes in under 5 minutes by comparing deliverables against your signed specifications - no manual intervention needed. For complex cases, human adjudicators and executive reviewers step in to make binding decisions within clear SLAs.

​
2. Step-by-Step Guide

Initiating a Dispute
  1. Navigate to the job where you’ve rejected the expert’s deliverable
  2. Click “Initiate Dispute” on the rejected submission
  3. Select a reason category: Spec Unclear, Requirements Not Achievable, Deliverable Wrongly Rejected, or Payment Issue
  4. Write a description of at least 50 characters explaining your concern
  5. Optionally attach up to 10 evidence files (50 MB max each) - screenshots, docs, or other proof
  6. Submit the dispute - your escrow freezes immediately to protect your funds
What Happens Next
  1. The expert receives an email notification with 48 hours to submit counter-evidence
  2. After the 48-hour window closes, AI automatically analyzes the case in under 5 minutes
  3. If the AI has high confidence (85%+), it issues a binding decision: Complete Payment, Require Rework, or Full Refund
  4. If the AI isn’t confident, a platform moderator reviews the full case package and decides within 48 hours
If You Disagree (High-Value Disputes Only)
  1. For disputes over $5,000, you can file an executive appeal within 24 hours of the adjudicator’s decision
  2. An executive reviewer examines the complete audit trail and issues a final, binding decision within 5 days
Outcomes
  • Complete Payment: Escrow releases to the expert within 60 seconds
  • Require Rework: The expert gets 7 days to fix specific unmet requirements, then AI re-checks
  • Full Refund: You receive your full escrow refund within 24 hours

​
3. Common Questions

How does the AI know if the expert met my requirements? The AI reads your signed specification line-by-line and compares each functional requirement (FR-XXX) against the delivered files. It marks each requirement as Met, Unmet, or Partial, then generates a confidence score. If it’s 85%+ confident, the decision is binding. The AI pulls exact excerpts from the deliverable to support its determination, so you can see the evidence. What if my specification was vague and both of us are right? The AI flags ambiguous specifications and escalates to a human adjudicator. The moderator reviews the spec, deliverables, and both parties’ evidence to make a fair call. If the spec genuinely lacks clear pass/fail criteria, the moderator may request clarification from both sides before deciding. Irreconcilable cases result in a full refund. Can I dispute a deliverable I already accepted? No. Once you accept a deliverable, you can’t initiate a dispute claiming defects. The dispute window opens only when you reject work. This prevents abuse and ensures disputes happen in real-time, not days later. What if the expert doesn’t submit counter-evidence within 48 hours? The AI proceeds with analysis anyway, using only your evidence and the deliverable itself. The expert’s silence doesn’t automatically mean you win - the AI still compares the work against your specification objectively. How do I know the process is fair and transparent? Every action - evidence submissions, AI analysis, adjudicator decisions, escrow movements - logs to an immutable audit trail. You can export the complete timeline as structured text or JSON. Both parties can access the audit log for 24 months post-resolution.

​
4. Troubleshooting

“An active dispute already exists for this job” error Only one dispute can be open per job at a time. If you see this error, check the Dispute List page (/disputes/disputelist) to view the existing dispute. You can add evidence to the current dispute rather than starting a new one. The expert submitted rework but new issues appeared If the expert fixes the originally unmet requirements but introduces new bugs, the system notifies the adjudicator for a final determination. The adjudicator may extend the rework deadline or issue a refund depending on the severity of the new issues. Escrow release failed after a Complete Payment decision If the expert’s Stripe Connect account is deactivated or blocked, the automatic release fails. Administrators receive an alert and resolve the payment manually within 24 hours. Your escrow remains frozen until the issue clears. I missed the 24-hour appeal window for a high-value dispute Executive appeals lock after 24 hours - no exceptions. If you’re concerned about missing deadlines, enable email notifications in Channel Preferences (/privacypreferences) to receive real-time alerts when decisions are issued. Escrow Dashboard - Track your protected funds in real-time. When a dispute opens, you’ll see the escrow status change from Funded to Held. Once the dispute resolves, watch escrow release or refund automatically based on the outcome. Client Review - Before rejecting work and triggering a dispute, use the Client Review workflow (/review/clientreview) to provide structured feedback. Many issues resolve without formal disputes when you give the expert clear, actionable revision requests. Expert Dashboard - If you’re also working as an expert on other jobs, check how disputes affect your reputation score. Three or more irreconcilable refunds trigger an account review, so you’ll want to monitor your standing.