Skip to main content

​
Corporate Innovation Evaluation Framework

​
Overview

The Corporate Innovation Evaluation Framework helps portfolio managers and innovation leads route initiatives through structured evaluation stages, calculate risk-weighted scores, and make data-driven decisions on where to invest resources. Instead of gut-feel judgments, you build evidence systematically - capturing strategic fit, value mechanisms, learning velocity, and economic potential - so you can confidently accelerate winners, pivot struggling initiatives, and stop losers before they drain resources.

​
Step-by-Step Guide

​
Creating and Routing a New Initiative

  1. Create the initiative - Navigate to Innovation Evaluation Wizard (/innovationevaluationwizard). Enter a title (minimum 5 characters) and brief description (minimum 20 characters). Select your portfolio from the dropdown. The system assigns a unique ID and timestamp automatically.
  2. Answer Stage 1: Context Configuration - Complete 5 routing questions on a single screen. These questions determine if your initiative is Core (optimizing existing business), Adjacent (expanding into new markets or customers), or Transformational (exploring entirely new business models). Expect this to take under 5 minutes. The system displays your routing decision with an explanation immediately after submission.
  3. Complete Stage 2: Strategic Intent - Answer 6 questions about strategic relevance and overlap with existing initiatives. The system auto-saves after each question. At this stage, the platform surfaces potential duplicates with a similarity percentage - any initiative scoring above 60% similarity is flagged. You can dismiss false positives or merge true duplicates. If your strategic relevance score falls below 40%, the system recommends STOP with rationale and offers a learning harvest option to capture insights before closing.
  4. Define Stage 3: Value Mechanism - Answer 5 questions about how your initiative creates value. Use the Trigger > Action > Outcome > Value prompt to map your complete value chain. All four components must be filled before you can progress. This stage clarifies exactly how customer behavior translates into business value.
  5. Assess Stage 4: Uncertainty & Learning - Complete 7 questions about critical unknowns and validation approach. Identify at least 3 critical unknowns. For each unknown, specify criticality level, current evidence status (Hypothesis only / Some signals / Strong evidence), and validation timeline. The system calculates your Learning Risk Index (0-100) in under 500ms. If you haven’t updated evidence in 4 weeks, the initiative appears in the “Stalled Learning” section.
  6. Estimate Stage 5: Economic Value - Provide value ranges (minimum / expected / maximum) and investment ranges with confidence levels. If your confidence is Low (variance over 100%), the system applies a 0.5x weight to your expected value. Medium confidence (50-100% variance) gets 0.75x weight. High confidence (under 50% variance) gets full 1.0x weight. Capture both financial and non-financial value dimensions.
  7. Review machine recommendation - The system generates a composite score using weighted dimensions: Strategic Relevance (20%), Value Clarity (15%), Learning Velocity (20%), Assumption Risk (15%), Expected Value (20%), Portfolio Fit (10%). Scores of 80+ trigger ACCELERATE recommendations. 60-79 suggests CONTINUE. 40-59 recommends PIVOT. Below 40 recommends STOP. You see the recommendation with supporting rationale displayed clearly.
  8. Make your decision - Accept the machine recommendation or override it. If you override, you must provide at least 50 characters of rationale. Both the machine recommendation and your decision are stored in the audit trail with timestamp and user ID.

​
Monitoring Portfolio Balance

  1. View portfolio dashboard - Access Portfolio Dashboard to see Core/Adjacent/Transformational balance. The default target bands are 70% Core / 20% Adjacent / 10% Transformational. If your portfolio skews more than 40% Transformational, the system surfaces a rebalancing recommendation with specific initiatives to pause or accelerate.
  2. Identify stalled initiatives - Check the “Needs Attention” section for initiatives with no evidence updates in 4 weeks (configurable threshold). These initiatives show a “Stalled Learning” warning flag. Click through to see which critical unknowns lack validation evidence.
  3. Track learning velocity - For active initiatives, view the Learning Velocity indicator showing progression from “Hypothesis only” to “Some signals” to “Strong evidence” for each critical unknown. Log evidence against unknowns to update this indicator and demonstrate learning momentum.

​
Common Questions

How does the system decide if my initiative is Core, Adjacent, or Transformational?
Stage 1 routing logic analyzes your responses to 5 context questions about customer targets, business model, capabilities required, and strategic distance from current operations. The algorithm produces consistent results given the same inputs and displays the routing decision with an explanation so you understand the classification. What happens if my initiative scores below 40% on strategic relevance?
The system recommends STOP with a detailed rationale. You’re offered a “learning harvest” option to capture insights before closing the initiative. This ensures valuable learnings aren’t lost even when an initiative doesn’t deserve further investment. The decision and rationale are logged in the audit trail. Can I compare initiatives with different confidence levels fairly?
Yes. The system applies confidence weighting to economic value calculations. Low confidence estimates (variance over 100%) are weighted at 0.5x, medium confidence (50-100% variance) at 0.75x, and high confidence (under 50% variance) at 1.0x. This prevents false precision and ensures conservative valuation of highly uncertain initiatives. Why can’t I skip ahead to the value estimation stage?
Sequential completion is enforced for scoring integrity. Each stage builds on the previous one - you can’t estimate value ranges without first defining your value mechanism, and you can’t assess learning risk without understanding strategic intent. The “Next Stage” button remains disabled until current stage validation passes. How do I know if my portfolio is balanced correctly?
The portfolio balance view shows your current distribution versus target bands (default: 70/20/10 for Core/Adjacent/Transformational). Visual indicators show deviation from targets. If you’re overweighted in any category - especially Transformational above 40% - the system surfaces rebalancing recommendations with specific initiatives to pause or accelerate. Note: Balance views require at least 5 initiatives in the portfolio to display.

​
Troubleshooting

My initiative isn’t progressing past Stage 2 even though I answered all questions
Check that you’ve dismissed or merged all duplicate candidates flagged by the system. Initiatives with unresolved duplicates (similarity above 60%) cannot progress until you explicitly dismiss them as false positives or merge them into a single initiative. Also verify that your stage completion triggered successfully - look for the progress indicator showing Stage 2 as complete. The Learning Velocity indicator hasn’t updated despite logging new evidence
Evidence updates must be logged against specific critical unknowns identified in Stage 4. Simply adding notes or attachments won’t update the indicator. Navigate to the initiative detail view, locate the critical unknowns section, and explicitly log evidence with the evidence level (Hypothesis only / Some signals / Strong evidence) for the update to register. The indicator refreshes within 500ms of valid evidence logging. Portfolio metrics seem outdated after I updated an initiative score
Portfolio-level metrics recalculate through a batch job that runs every 30 seconds for portfolios up to 500 initiatives. If your portfolio is larger, allow up to 60 seconds for recalculation. Force a manual recalculation by refreshing the Portfolio Dashboard page. If metrics still appear stale, verify that the underlying initiative scores saved successfully by checking the score history on the initiative detail page. I can’t find an initiative I created last week
Check the initiative status filter in your portfolio view. Archived initiatives are excluded from active portfolio calculations but remain visible in historical analysis views. Also verify you’re viewing the correct portfolio - initiatives must be associated with a portfolio and cannot exist independently. Use the search function with the initiative title or unique ID to locate it across all portfolios you have access to. Data Room Management - Store supporting documents, investor materials, and validation evidence in structured data rooms linked to your initiatives. The Data Room automatically organizes content by stage and generates gap analyses showing which investor readiness sections need completion. Connect this to initiatives in Stage 5 when you need to demonstrate traction to potential investors or internal stakeholders. Feature Evaluation Framework - For initiatives that progress to implementation, use the Feature Evaluation system to prioritize specific product features through multi-gate scoring. This connects naturally after Stage 5 when you’ve validated strategic fit and economic potential and need to decide which capabilities to build first. Feature Evaluation applies similar scoring logic but focuses on implementation feasibility and user impact. Lifecycle Journey Tracking - Monitor how initiatives progress through broader venture lifecycle stages from ideation to scale. The Journey framework provides task-level granularity and milestone tracking that complements the initiative evaluation scores. Use this when an initiative graduates from evaluation into active execution - it tracks delivery progress while the Innovation Framework continues monitoring strategic performance.